| Year | Name |
| 1944 | John Fenstermaker |
| 1945 | Clayton Arnold (Potentate of Al Koran 1954) |
| 1946 | Charles E. Jonas |
| 1947 | Lionel F. Ashbolt |
| 1948 | Karl Fricker |
| 1949 | Ben Wetter |
| 1950 | Edmund J. Harig |
| 1951 | John W. Cope |
| 1952 | Chester S. Giltz |
| 1953 | Henry D. Thomas (Potentate of Al Koran 1966) |
| 1953 | K. M. Blocker |
| 1954 | Earl C. Henderson |
| 1955 | J. A. Shaidnagle Jr. |
| 1956 | Wilbur Jenkins |
| 1957 | Forest G. Thomas |
| 1958 | Walter A. Smith |
| 1959 | Jack Fox |
| 1960 | Harold D. Kurtz |
| 1961 | Wayne Arnold |
| 1962 | John Q. Adams |
| 1963 | Robert E. McFadden |
| 1964 | Borman R. Weise |
| 1965 | Billy J. Reese |
| 1965 | William C. Bell |
| 1966 | Marion Graber |
| 1967 | Harry Syrios |
| 1968 | William T. Tyrrell |
| 1969 | Charles R. Henderson |
| 1970 | Clarence Rambuad |
| 1971 | Leon Martin |
| 1972 | Willard Mottice |
| 1973 | Walter A. Tucker |
| 1974 | Ray Twiggs |
| 1975 | Harold Malone |
| 1976 | Robert Dittmar |
| 1977 | Jacob Reinerts Jr. |
| 1978 | William A. Reinerts |
| 1979 | Maurice Mannweiler |
| 1980 | Wayne Spies |
| 1981 | Edward Urban |
| 1982 | Joseph Weisgarber |
| 1983 | Edward Urban |
| 1984 | Gene D. Lynch |
| 1985 | Jack Robinson |
| 1986 | Billy F. Wilson |
| 1987 | James E. Johnson |
| 1988 | James Youngman |
| 1989 | Don Lint |
| 1990 | Carl McCalla |
| 1991 | Larry Kandle |
| 1992 | David Wigginton |
| 1993 | Jim Henderson |
| 1994 | Donald Kandle |
| 1995 | Robert Palmer |
| 1996 | George Bretz |
| 1997 | Greg Mong |
| 1998 | Dale Kandle |
| 1999 | John Boyd |
| 2000 | Bill Kemp |
| 2001 | Cliff Crew |
| 2002 | Jim Dawson |
| 2003 | BJ Johnson |
| 2004 | Denny Bowe |
| 2005 | Don Harwig |
| 2006 | Scott Hallett |
| 2007 | Steve Nevel |